St Michaels Patna Scores Once Again In New Delhi This Time Around...

St Michaels Patna Scores Once Again In New Delhi This Time Around CIC


Yashovardhan Azad, a Michaelite from ST Michaels School Patna 19 69 batch and a distinguished IPS Officer, has just retired as one of the Information Commissioner at the office of CIC. However yashwardhan Kumar Sinha, another Michaelite from Patna from the 1974 batch, a distinguished IFS Officer has taken his place. Whereas the senior Yash was the son of Shri Bhagwat Jha, former CM of Bihar and elder brother of Cricketer & MP Kirti Azad, the Junior Yash is son of General SK Sinha.He is 1981 batch IFS Officer who has served as the High Commissioner of India in UK and Colombo.
Sinha had also served a number of important postings in the Ministry of External Affairs including the crucial Pakistan-Afghanistan-Iran Division, which he headed for four years as Additional Secretary.

With Shakti Sinha of 1972 batch Michaels as Director Nehru Memorial Museum & Library and Navin Sinha again of 1972 batch Michaels a Judge of the Supreme Court, the list gains significance. Add to this the fact that Air Chief Marshal BS Dhanoa too was from the same Michaels – Xavier’s Patna before moving to RIMC, Dehradun. His father a former Election Commissioner was a Bihar Cadre IAS Officer.

Sudhir Bhargava has been appointed as the new chief information commissioner (CIC) along with four new information commissioners in the central information commission which had been functioning with just three of them as against a sanctioned strength of 11, including the chief information commissioner. Highly placed sources said Bhargava, one of the information commissioner in the CIC, has been appointed as new chief of the panel.

President Ram Nath Kovind has also approved the appointment of former IFS officer Yashwardhan Kumar Sinha, former IRS officer Vanaja N Sarna, former IAS Neeraj Kumar Gupta and former law secretary Suresh Chandra as information commissioners in the central information commission, a government order accessed by said.

The only woman in the CIC will be Sarna, a 1980-batch indian revenue service (customs and excise) officer, who was the chief of central board of excise and customs (CBEC). Neeraj Kumar Gupta, a 1982-batch IAS officer, was secretary in the department of investment and public asset management.Chandra, an Indian legal service officer, retired as Union law secretary this year and was also private secretary to the then law minister Arun Jaitley between 2002 and 2004.

All the bureaucrats appointed by the government have retired this year.
After recent retirements of chief information commissioner R K Mathur and information commissioners Yashovardhan Azad, Sridhar Acharyulu and Amitava Bhattacharyya, the Commission, the highest adjudicating authority in RTI matters, was left with three information commissioners, prompting activists to approach the Supreme Court on the issue of vacancies.

The Supreme Court had asked the Centre and states to maintain transparency in appointments of chief information commissioner and information commissioners and upload the details of search committees and applicants on website.Commenting on the appointment process, Commodore Lokesh Batra, one of the petitioners in the case, said the government has failed to comply with the Supreme Court directions of posting the details on website.

“As my gut feeling said, the government did not comply with the Supreme Court directions viz transparency as it did not post details on its website,” Batra told.During the hearing, the Centre had told the top court that the search committee has shortlisted names for the post of CIC and a final decision will be taken soon.

A bench of Justices A K Sikri, S Abdul Nazeer and R Subhash Reddy asked the Centre to put on the website details of search committee for CIC and ICs.The Centre seems to have ignored plea of former information commissioner Sridhar Acharyulu who had called for adequate representation of non-bureaucrats in the Commission in accordance with the Right to Information (RTI) Act.
Citing Section 12 (5) of the RTI Act, he had written to the President that the Act provides for selecting people of eminence, having experience in law, science and technology, social service, management, journalism, mass media or administration and governance.

If the government selects more number of former bureaucrats for these posts, it will be a breach of the letter and spirit of the transparency law and more particularly that of Section 12(5) of the RTI Act, which may not stand the scrutiny by the judiciary, he argued.

Additional solicitor general Pinky Anand, appearing for the Centre, had informed the court that a total of 65 applications were recived for the CIC post and 280 applications for the post of four ICs in the Central Information Commission. She had said that after these posts are filled up, notification will be issued for inviting applications for remaining posts of ICs.